A Win Against the Odds: C11 Approval After IRCC’s Policy Overhaul 

Managing Lawyer

How an Entrepreneur from India Overcame the Odds to Secure Her C11 Work Permit in Canada

Ashu (not her real name), an entrepreneur from India, came to us in a state of urgency. Her family had invested heavily in a promising opportunity—a burger franchise in Toronto. But just a few months into operations, it became painfully clear: the business was losing money, and without her on-site leadership, it was unlikely to survive.

Her odds of a work permit approval were not strong. She had no background in the food industry, her ties to her home country were limited (as her whole family sought to relocate), and the business was in a highly saturated fast food market. 

Still, Ashu chose to fight rather than walk away. She asked us to help her take one last shot at turning things around—and we committed to giving it everything we had. 

Our Role and Scope

Our firm was retained to provide comprehensive legal and strategic support in Canadian immigration. This included: 

  • Assessing whether Ashu’s case could meet the C11 work permit threshold 
  • Helping her develop a practical and compelling business turnaround strategy 
  • Preparing a robust, IRCC-aligned business plan to support the work permit application 
  • Identifying and gathering the strongest possible evidences to support her application 
  • Drafting a detailed submission to IRCC that would anticipate and address the case’s inherent challenges

We were upfront with Ashu: this would not be an easy win. However, we would present the best possible case with complete transparency and a carefully executed strategy. 

Complexities and Challenges

Ashu’s case included nearly every red flag the IRCC warns about:

  • Industry Saturation: Toronto’s fast food scene is extremely crowded, and the franchise lacks a prominent innovation component.
  • Loss-Making Business: The business was actively losing money and already struggling.
  • No Sector Experience: Ashu had never worked in the restaurant industry in Canada or abroad.
  • Weak Home Ties: Her whole family intended to relocate, undermining her “temporary intent.”
  • Partnership Dynamics: The business was shared with a Canadian partner, and precise control and benefits needed to be established. 

Each of these could have led to a refusal on its own.

Our Approach To Avoid Work Permit Rejection

Despite these obstacles, our team carefully crafted a narrative of business credibility and regional benefit. Here’s how we addressed the key challenges: 

  • Competition & Market Saturation: We emphasized how the business would fill a gap in service quality, cultural relevance, and accessibility—particularly within a demographic underserved by mainstream providers.
  • Financial Struggles: We provided a detailed recovery plan backed by capital infusion, operational improvements, and a clear value proposition. This showed the IRCC that the applicant was not entering a failing venture but investing in its revitalization.
  • Lack of Experience: Through affidavits, academic records, and related personal ventures, we highlighted transferable entrepreneurial skills and a strong capacity for adaptation. We also emphasized her Canadian partner’s expertise, demonstrating operational support and mentorship.
  • Weak Home Ties: We provided credible evidence of extended family, property, and financial obligations in India and included a detailed exit strategy showing how the business could operate without her direct, long-term involvement.

Our submission was comprehensive and transparent, acknowledging the case’s complexities while articulating why the application met—and even exceededthe revised C11 work permit threshold for “significant benefit.” 

Outcome

The application was submitted on 14 April 2025 and received a positive decision on 4 June 2025—just days after IRCC’s new C11 guidance came into effectDespite the higher bar, IRCC found the case compelling and granted Ashu a 2-year work permit under the C11 exemption. 

 

Why Was It Successful?

This case succeeded not because it was “perfect” but because it was honest, strategic, and supported by clear documentation. IRCC’s officers, even under the new regime, are still open to well-argued, transparent cases where the applicant demonstrates a genuine business need, operational readiness, and a benefit to Canada. 

What made the difference? 

  • Honest Framing: We didn’t hide the weaknesses. We addressed each one directly, with clear documentation and logical arguments. 
  • Evidence-Based: From financials to operational readiness, every claim was backed by concrete proof. 
  • Strategic Storytelling: We crafted a narrative emphasizing real economic benefit, community impact, and a clear roadmap to sustainability. 
  • Policy Alignment: We carefully mapped the application against IRCC’s updated C11 expectations, including ownership, job creation, regional value, and temporary intent

Ready to Build Your Future in Canada?

If you’re an entrepreneur looking to navigate the evolving C11 landscape, don’t leave your future to chance. IRCC is no longer approving hopeful ideas—it’s rewarding strategic execution. 

Let our team help you craft a winning application grounded in reality, impact, and intent. 

Contact us today to explore whether the C11 pathway is right for you.

Our Strategic Solution

Rather than defending the test scores alone, x ability and real-world performance. We didn’t just claim that Van Minh could communicate effectively. We proved it with:

  • Screenshots of daily operational messages with staff
  • Handwritten work notes demonstrating task coordination
  • Photos of equipment repairs he directed using simple English + gestures
  • Letters from employees explaining how they work together seamlessly

We also leveraged Federal Court precedents that emphasized functional ability over academic testing:

“The relevant standard is whether the applicant can perform their actual duties—not whether they meet arbitrary language thresholds.” – Singh v. Canada (2022)

The Outcome: Approval Granted

The IRCC approved a two-year extension of our client’s C11 work permit. This success preserved 10+ local jobs and sustained a critical food processing business in a rural community.

Related article: C11 Work Permit Renewal as a Business Owner: What You Should Know.

Why This Victory Matters for YOU

If you’re an entrepreneur worried about:

  • Language test scores that aren’t perfect
  • Complex business structures
  • C11 extension applications
  • High refusal rates & IRCC’s increasing scrutiny

This case proves there’s always a path forward.

The C11 program rewards results, not test scores. Business impact, not linguistic perfection. Real-world success, not classroom theory.

 

Ready to Turn Your C11 Challenge into Your Success Story?

The immigration landscape is evolving rapidly. What worked five years ago might fail today. What seems impossible today might be entirely achievable with the right strategy.

Our team specializes in building solid C11 applications that anticipate challenges and turn potential weaknesses into compelling strengths. We’ve mastered the art of showing IRCC exactly what they want to see: entrepreneurs who deliver measurable value to Canada.

📞 Schedule your confidential consultation today

During this strategy session, we’ll:

✅ Analyze your unique business situation
✅ Identify potential application challenges
✅ Design a custom approach for maximum success
✅ Give you honest assessment of your approval odds

Because your business success shouldn’t depend on a language test score.

Legal Fine Print (The Boring But Important Stuff)

This success story is shared for educational purposes and doesn’t constitute legal advice. Every immigration case is unique, with different facts, circumstances, and outcomes. Past results don’t guarantee future success.

Client details have been anonymized to protect confidentiality. Current C11 requirements may differ from those described here.

For personalized legal guidance about your specific situation, consult with qualified immigration counsel. Laws and policies change frequently, so independent verification of current requirements is essential.

This content reflects our understanding of the law at the time of writing and shouldn’t be relied upon without current legal verification.

Make Your First Step Towards Canada

👋 Hi! I'm LIA
×
LIA Avatar

Hi, I'm LIA

Your AI Immigration Assistant

👋 I'm here to help you explore Canadian business immigration options — specifically for investors, entrepreneurs, and business owners.

How it works: We'll chat for up to 60 minutes. I'll ask a few questions, suggest immigration pathways, and answer yours. I’ll notify you when 15 minutes remain.

📌 What I Can (and Can't) Do:

  • Not legal advice — I guide your search; for legal help, book a strategy meeting.
  • Business immigration only — no help with refugee claims, family sponsorships, or job search.
I Understand and Agree

Already Have Premium? Login